However, when Jhoulys Chacin returned from a back injury, the Rockies optioned the guy who replaced him, Tyler Chatwood, who had gone 1-0 with a 3.00 ERA in two starts. Now, against the Yankees, Nicasio has a chance to prove his worth.
"I know I haven't done the job; I know how the big leagues work," Nicasio said. "But I know I can throw more than five innings. I need [to pitch] better, quick."
Nicasio has recorded 20 strikeouts and 15 walks in 29 1/3 innings. Often, the issue is that Nicasio gets two strikes on a batter but lacks the ability to put him away. Veteran hitters are able to foul off pitch after pitch and often work a walk.
Nicasio can help his efficiency by either finding a more effective way to use his strikeout pitch or forcing more ground balls, which is the M.O. the Rockies prefer for their pitchers. The right-hander's four-seam fastball, which has movement but is not always low enough in the strike zone, is his best pitch. Nicasio does have confidence in his slider, but his changeup, a pitch he barely used last year, is one that he hasn't used with full confidence. Whatever pitch he chooses, Nicasio is looking to settle counts quicker.
"If my fastball is down and it moves, I can have a lot of ground balls, but right now, I don't quite have command of my fastball," Nicasio said. "Right now, I get to two strikes and I try to do too much with my fastball or throw breaking balls in the dirt.
"I looked at my 2011 video, and I went after hitters with two strikes. Now, I'm being careful. Now, I want to go no more than four pitches for a hitter. That's the mentality that I'm working on."
Manager Walt Weiss likes Nicasio's heavy fastball and believes that developing his other pitches will help the 24-year-old use his fastball to the fullest.
"The slider is a good pitch for him," Weiss said. "He didn't throw as many changeups his last time out. His confidence has been growing with the changeup. That's the one that, if he gets more confidence in throwing that pitch, it'll give him more wiggle room with his fastball."
Chatwood threw a complete-game four-hitter on Tuesday in Colorado Springs' 5-0 victory over the Iowa Cubs at Colorado Springs. It was the first shutout for a Colorado Springs starter since Brandon Hynick threw a seven-inning perfect game against Portland on June 30, 2009.
It also was the first home shutout -- Colorado Springs plays at an altitude even higher than that of Coors Field -- for the Sky Sox since 2003.